englishhelp.pl

C1 Advanced Reading Part 5 5

C1 Advanced Reading Multiple Choice – test 5. Tekst to esej o etyce ogrodów zoologicznych, który przedstawia argumenty zwolenników i krytyków zoo. Pytania sprawdzają, czy odróżniasz opinię autora od poglądów, które on tylko relacjonuje.

C1 Advanced Reading Multiple Choice – etyka ogrodów zoologicznych

Tekst znajdziesz poniżej, a pytania pod nim. W egzaminie Reading and Use of English Part 5 to jeden długi tekst i 6 pytań wielokrotnego wyboru. Tutaj jest tak samo: 6 pytań w kolejności tekstu, a ostatnie często dotyczy całości. Najczęściej sprawdzają:

  • opinię i nastawienie autora (attitude, purpose),
  • znaczenie wyrażeń i porównań w kontekście,
  • szczegóły ukryte w parafrazie – poprawna odpowiedź rzadko powtarza słowa z tekstu.

Test 5 z serii C1 Advanced Reading Multiple Choice – połowa cyklu. W esejach argumentacyjnych zwracaj uwagę na słowa sygnalizujące zastrzeżenia: yet, however, with some justification, although.

What are zoos for?

Few institutions provoke such divided feelings as the modern zoo. For some visitors, a day spent watching gorillas and giraffes is a cherished family tradition; for others, the sight of a polar bear pacing a concrete enclosure is an image of everything that is wrong with our relationship to the natural world. Both reactions are understandable, and both, I want to suggest, rest on an outdated picture of what zoos are for.

The zoos of the nineteenth century were, quite openly, places of entertainment and display. Animals were collected much as stamps or paintings were collected: to impress, to amuse and to demonstrate the reach of empire. Little thought was given to their welfare, and many died within months of arrival. It is this legacy that critics have in mind when they call for zoos to be closed, and it would be foolish to pretend it has entirely disappeared.

Yet the best modern zoos have changed almost beyond recognition. Their enclosures are designed around the needs of the animals rather than the sightlines of visitors, which means, to the frequent frustration of the paying public, that the animals are sometimes impossible to see. Their stated purpose is no longer display but conservation: breeding endangered species, funding projects in the wild and conducting research that would be impossible elsewhere.

The conservation argument is powerful, but it deserves closer scrutiny than it usually receives. Only a small proportion of the species kept in zoos are actually endangered, and fewer still are part of programmes that aim to return animals to the wild. Reintroduction is difficult, expensive and frequently unsuccessful. Critics point out, with some justification, that zoos tend to favour charismatic species that attract visitors – elephants, big cats, pandas – over less appealing creatures whose need may be greater.

Defenders reply that this is precisely the point. The popular animals pay for the unglamorous work. Visitors who come to see the lions also, perhaps unknowingly, fund the breeding of rare frogs and insects behind the scenes. Moreover, for many urban children, a zoo provides the only opportunity to encounter a wild animal in person, and there is some evidence that such encounters foster lasting concern for the natural world, although the evidence is less conclusive than zoos sometimes claim.

The question, then, is not whether zoos are good or bad in the abstract, but whether particular zoos justify keeping particular animals. Some species – those that range over vast distances, such as polar bears and orcas – seem to suffer in captivity however generous the enclosure. There is a strong case for phasing them out. Others appear to thrive, breed readily and show few signs of stress.

What is needed is not abolition but honesty. Zoos should be judged by what they achieve for conservation, not by what they say in their marketing, and visitors should be encouraged to understand that an empty-looking enclosure may be a sign of good practice rather than poor value. That would require a considerable shift in public expectations. But then, the history of zoos is itself a history of shifting expectations, and there is no reason to believe it has reached its end.

1. In paragraph 1, the writer suggests that both supporters and critics of zoos
2. What does the writer admit at the end of paragraph 2?
3. What is the writer’s attitude to the conservation argument in paragraph 4?
4. According to the defenders of zoos, popular animals
5. The writer mentions polar bears and orcas as examples of animals that
6. What does the writer conclude in the final paragraph?